Auto Insurance Provider Ratings

In my quest to switch from Farmers Auto Insurance, I found provider ratings from the J.D. Power Consumer Center. The insurance companies are rated from 1-5 based on Overall Experience, Policy Offerings, Pricing, and Contacting Insurer. Based on this data I think we will give Geico a try and bypass seeing an agent for now.

The #1 Award Recipient went to Amica Mutual with a perfect score.

2. AARP with a perfect score
3. Erie 4 out of 5 on all categories
4. State Farm 4 out of 5 on all but 3 out of five for pricing
5. Geico faired very well 4 out of 5 for pricing and policy offerings, but average 3 out of 5 for overall experience and contact insurer

Allstate, American Family, and Hartford all about the average 3 out of 5